Results of the trials evaluating the role of tandem autologous stem cell transplantation (ASCT) versus ASCT followed by allogeneic reduced-intensity chemotherapy (Allo-RIC).
. | Tandem Auto vs Auto/Allo-RIC . | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cooperative Group . | Patients . | CR, % . | EFS, mo . | OS, mo . | P . | Ref. . |
*Only high-risk patients (high β2-microglobulin and/or del(13q); worse survival for patients with del(13q) | ||||||
**Only patients with < CR/nCR after first ASCT | ||||||
†Patients after first ASCT were randomized to receive maintenance versus Allo-RIC | ||||||
S indicates significant P-value; NS, non-significant P-value | ||||||
IFM* | 166 vs 46 | 37 vs 55 | 25 vs 21 | 57 vs 41 | NS | 35 |
GIMEMA | 82 vs 80 | 26 vs 55 | 33 vs 37 | 64 vs NR | S | 36 |
PETHEMA** | 82 vs 25 | 11 vs 40 | 20 vs 26 | 58 vs 60 | NS | 37 |
HOVON† | 101 vs 115 | 42 vs 45 | 34 vs 39 | 63 vs 56 | NS | 38 |
EBMT | 250 vs 110 | 41 vs 52 | 15 vs 36 | 50 vs 65 | S | 39 |
. | Tandem Auto vs Auto/Allo-RIC . | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cooperative Group . | Patients . | CR, % . | EFS, mo . | OS, mo . | P . | Ref. . |
*Only high-risk patients (high β2-microglobulin and/or del(13q); worse survival for patients with del(13q) | ||||||
**Only patients with < CR/nCR after first ASCT | ||||||
†Patients after first ASCT were randomized to receive maintenance versus Allo-RIC | ||||||
S indicates significant P-value; NS, non-significant P-value | ||||||
IFM* | 166 vs 46 | 37 vs 55 | 25 vs 21 | 57 vs 41 | NS | 35 |
GIMEMA | 82 vs 80 | 26 vs 55 | 33 vs 37 | 64 vs NR | S | 36 |
PETHEMA** | 82 vs 25 | 11 vs 40 | 20 vs 26 | 58 vs 60 | NS | 37 |
HOVON† | 101 vs 115 | 42 vs 45 | 34 vs 39 | 63 vs 56 | NS | 38 |
EBMT | 250 vs 110 | 41 vs 52 | 15 vs 36 | 50 vs 65 | S | 39 |