Survival or death of individual proerythroblasts results from differing erythropoietin sensitivities: a mechanism for controlled rates of erythrocyte production

Murine erythroid progenitors infected with the anemia-inducing strain of Friend virus (FVA cells) undergo apoptosis when deprived of erythropoietin (EPO). When cultured with EPO, they survive and complete terminal differentiation. Although cell volume is decreased and nuclear chromatin is condensed during both apoptosis and terminal differentiation, morphologic and biochemical distinctions between these two processes were observed. In apoptosis, homogeneous nuclear condensation with nuclear envelope loss occurred in cells that had not reached the stage of hemoglobin synthesis. In terminal erythroid differentiation, nuclear condensation with heterochromatin, euchromatin, and nuclear envelope preservation occurred simultaneously with hemoglobin synthesis. Cells with apoptotic morphology appeared asynchronously in EPO-deprived cultures, indicating that only a portion of the cells were undergoing apoptosis at any given time. The percentages of apoptotic cells and cleaved DNA increased with time in EPO-deprived cultures. Inhibition of DNA cleavage was directly proportional to EPO concentration over a wide physiologic range, demonstrating a heterogeneity in susceptibility to apoptosis based on variability in the EPO sensitivity of individual cells. A subpopulation of FVA cells with increased EPO sensitivity (decreased EPO requirement) was isolated from EPO-deprived cultures. This increased EPO sensitivity did not result from differences in EPO receptor number, affinity, or structure, suggesting that the differences are in the signal transduction pathway. These results indicate that control of red blood cell production involves both prevention of apoptosis by EPO and heterogeneity in the EPO requirement of individual progenitor cells.