Abstract
Background: Outcomes of unselected adult ALL patients (pts) have not been well studied at a population level. Whether such pts behave differently to those in formal clinical trials is unclear. We developed a uniform therapeutic protocol as the provincial standard of care in Manitoba, a province with 1.2 million people, for adult pts since 1989 (“ALL89-1”). The aim of this retrospective study was: to ascertain the local epidemiology of adult ALL; to analyze the efficacy and toxicity of the ALL89-1 regimen and any other regimens given to pts in a population-based setting.
Methods: All pts aged ≥18 years (yrs) diagnosed with ALL in Manitoba between 01/1989 and 11/2004 were identified via the provincial cancer registry. A review of computerized and paper charts was conducted. We focused on demographics, diagnostic clinical characteristics, therapy, treatment related toxicities, and whether stem cell transplantation (SCT) was performed.
Results: There were 81 pts with a median age of 44yrs (range, 18–90). 53 (65%) pts were male. 58 pts received ALL89-1, 12 received other regimens and 11 patients received palliation only. Thirteen pts were Philadelphia chromosome positive (Ph+). Complete remission (CR) rate after one cycle of induction therapy was 74% for all pts, and 74% for ALL89-1 pts. At a median follow-up of 56 months (range 7–265), estimated overall survival (OS) and leukemia free survival (LFS) at 5 years was 26% (95% Confidence interval [C.I.], 15–36) and 24%( 95% C.I. 14–35). The 5 year OS and LFS for the ALL89–1 group was 23% (95% C.I. 11–35) and 20% (95% C.I. 8–32). There were 13 treatment related deaths in the 58 ALL 89-1 pts, 4 of whom died post SCT. In multivariate analysis for all 81 pts, attainment of CR post induction chemotherapy independently predicted improved survival (hazard ratio 0.23, 95% C.I. 0.11–0.5). In contrast, age > 55yrs, Ph+ status, and high WBC at diagnosis were not significant survival predictors. Palliative pts survived for a median of 10 days (range, 0–53) from diagnosis.
Conclusions: This comprehensive province-wide study of adult ALL pts treated at a single cancer centre shows that durable leukemia free survival is possible, but for only a small subgroup. These results appear inferior to results of published clinical trials. The reasons for the relatively poor outcomes require further analysis in this and other jurisdictions.
Author notes
Corresponding author
